Pizza in Carle Place

“Since I started working in this area, I always grabbed a slice of pizza from Angelo’s atleast 2x a week. The staff is always friendly, such a wide variety of pizzas and super reasonable they sell their slices for! Great for a quick bite but I also love how deliciously unique their pizzas taste! I Highly recommend!”

“We ordered the Angelo's Special and the BBQ Chicken pizza... 10 out of 10 experience for both... The crust... the sauce... the taste! Superior! Staffer Monday night was super sweet and friendly when my husband and I came in; "W" customer service! Next time we're in town will definitely return.”

“The pizza was flavorful and crispy I like the crust everything was beutiful”

“They have a great selection of toppings to add to your pizza and its made fresh. The customer service is also very very good.”

“I had one slice of a reg pizza and it truly was great. I've had others around this area but this was the first time at this location. I can't comment on any of the other items on their menu. Would definitely go back for pizza though.”

“I moved to South Carolina from Long Island about 9 years ago. This pizza brought back memories of growing up here. Amazing food. Long Island atmosphere. This is the essence of New York pizza.”

“Outstanding pie, great ambience inside and really liked outside seating options”

“As a permanent Floridian, I miss great pizza. I was lucky enough to find Angelo's while visiting Garden City. Wow! The Grandma pizza was perfection. Great staff, fantastic pizza and salads.”

“Amazing pizza! We come here all the time after long shopping hours in Simon Mall. The pizza is outstanding, and we enjoy eating here. The restaurant is very clean inside, and is very modern. Overall, 11/10!”

“Got a pizza slice and beef patty to go and they were definitely fresher than the typical NYC pizzeria’s offerings.”

“10 out of 10, would recommend! This place was DELICIOUS! The staff are so kind and were even funny when I was joking with them! The pizza was DIVINE! Loved the atmosphere and taste. I can never eat pizza anywhere else ever again. Instant favorite!”

“I like the food, especially God father pizza :)”

“Moved to NC 9 yes ago... in town for family business and got angelo..... best pizza I've had in years .... THATS AMORE”

“Every time I come here, the pizza is delicious, and the hard working staff are always kind and friendly. One of my favorite pizza spots for sure !”

“Me and my dad were last minute shopping for some suits. So we decided to stop for a slice. Coal oven heaven babbbby. It was yummy. The pizza was burned to perfection. Highly recommend.”

“Angelo’s Pizzeria is absolutely amazing! We travel all the way from Queens to Long Island just for their pizza —my daughter insists it’s the best Margherita pizza she’s ever had. The restaurant is clean, the staff is friendly and attentive, and we love that they offer outdoor seating during the warmer months. Highly recommend!”

“Great pizza with a variety of flavors.”

“A friend had told me about Angelo's Pizzeria , so I had to try it, and It was Amazing!! What a variety of pizzas they have. Everything looked so fresh! On the way there, I was thinking about getting a Gyro, but once I saw the Pizza, I forgot about the Gyro, maybe next time! The staff really makes you feel welcome. The place has a good vibe. I can't wait to go back!”

“Angelo's Pizzeria and Ristorante makes a great impression. I ordered the Vodka and Margarita slices, which were some of the best I've had in New York. The owner is friendly and down-to-earth, adding to the positive experience. Whether you're nearby or not, it's worth a visit. I'll definitely be back!”

“My favorite pizza spot. The pizza crust amd bottom or cooked well crispy crust. Flavorable pizza! Affordable and the cheese has great pull 10/10”

“Normal pizzeria Sicilian pizza was great”

“Pizza was amazing and staff was friendly”

“Best pizza around town, especially the Sicilian pizza.”

“I come here to have some awesome pizza at Angelos after a day of snagging some goodies at tjmaxx!. The Sicilian and margherita pizza are my top favorites even the regular cheese is great!. You can’t go wrong with this place if you’re looking for some awesome pizza after a day of shopping at tj maxx!.”

“Always a great pizza pie my go to Pizza spot”

“Best pizza and white clam sauce in the area. Friendly staff and even friendlier owner.”

“Angelo's Pizza is the very best I've ever had since I was 4 years old and my Sicilian Grandma took me shopping to Bathgate Avenue in the Bronx in the '40's!! Thin crust, incredible sauce, delicate mozzarella and spices! I sat in the restaurant section and watched the chef make a Margaritas pizza while I ate mine! It was incredible!! ...and my second slice was a regular cheese. OMG! MOLTO delicioso!!”

“Was looking for an authentic place for a slice of NY pie. Found exactly what I was looking for, no flop, creamy cheese, great sauce! Value for the money as well.”

“Was the best pizza I ever tried and they were very nice”

“Pizza & ziti were really delicious and staff was incredibly nice!!”